I stood at the counter recently at a local Dunkin’ Donuts shop, perplexed. They had both of my favorite donuts on the shelves, the Chocolate Stick and the Vanilla Cake Batter. I was befuddled by which donut I should choose. The chocolate stick is easy to hold and eat and makes very little mess when eaten in a car. The vanilla cake batter donut has a delicious filling that makes me go, “Ahhhh.” What about not getting a donut at all? They are full of fat and bad chemicals that only cause problems for my body. Should I not even bother with a donut? I thought. It was quite a vexing moment for me. I didn’t know what to do. I was torn.
I feel this same baffled way about the teaching resource Mindful Teaching and Teaching Mindfulness by Deborah Schoeberlein David that I recently finished reading. While it filled my mind with lots of great ideas to implement in the classroom, it was poorly organized and overly repetitive. So, do I give it a rave review and not mention how disorganized the text felt throughout or do I give it an honest review mentioning both the good and bad aspects of the book? So, like I did that day at the doughnut shop, I paused, took a deep breath, and made my decision: Honesty is always the best policy. So, here it is, my honest review of the professional development resource regarding mindfulness.
Mental food for thought:
- The book is very disorganized and repetitive as the author keeps telling us the same thing over and over again regarding mindfulness and how to live mindfully. While she breaks the concept down into tiny pieces, the definitions and methods are almost always the same. Due to this chaos within the book, it felt clunky and I found myself skimming over several parts and chapters because they were all providing the reader with the same information. This aspect made the text hard to digest effectively as I constantly found myself thinking, She already told us this, throughout the book. Had she organized it in a more meaningful, succinct, and appropriate manner, I would have found much more enjoyment in the entire reading experience.
- After reading this text, I realized that I am already doing some of the mindful practices the author suggests, which also reminded me that not all new teaching practices are completely new and unique. Some concepts and ideas are things effective teachers already do on a regular basis, with mindfulness being one of them. I’ve felt as though the big push recently in education is about teaching students to be mindful. So, as one of my professional goals is to craft a mindfulness curriculum this summer, I felt compelled to read up on the topic so that I had some sort of foundation on which to build my curriculum. As I read the book, I realized that a big part of being mindful is reflecting in the moment and after the fact. I already do this on a daily basis through my teaching blog. At the close of each and every day of teaching, I stop, reflect on something that went well or crashed and burned that day, and then write about it. This process allows me to see how I can become a better educator since I am able to see the mistakes I made or celebrate my greatness. In reflecting, I’m also able to, sometimes, generate possible solutions to problems facing me as a teacher. Over the past few years that I’ve been blogging and reflecting, I’ve been able to focus my thinking in the moment. I find myself thinking about what is going well or not as I’m teaching, which allows me to make any alterations needed right then and there. So, while this idea of mindfulness seemed new and strange to me at first, I’m realizing that I am already on the path of being a mindful teacher, which means that I can model good, mindful practices for my students.
- Mindfulness is all about taking the time to live in the moment and truly experience life. I wonder then, if my school’s schedule is more conducive to mindlessness than it is mindfulness. We have short class blocks, which do not allow most teachers to delve into mindfulness practices. Our school is driven by time and schedule, which means that most students and teachers are always looking at the clock and not able to be present in the moment. While our sixth grade schedule is much more flexible, and we reiterate the importance of not living by the clock or time constraints in the classroom at the start of the year, as a whole school, we struggle to build in time for mindfulness. How can we expect our teachers to teach mindfulness to our students if we don’t provide them with the time to be mindful in the first place? For our school to truly help students be more mindful in and out of the classroom, our schedule and mindset as an institution needs to change. We need longer class periods and more time to work with the students on living in the moment and not worrying about what comes next. We need more time to pause and reflect with our students. I worry that while my co-teacher and I will teach our students to be more mindful this coming year, if our school doesn’t value mindfulness as a whole, then when our sixth graders move into the other graders, all of the effort and work they put into being mindful will be lost.
- Teaching students to be mindful involves teaching them about the brain and how it works. Once the students know how their brain helps them learn while also trying to distract them at every turn, they can begin to see how they can control their line of thinking and change their mindset. While my co-teacher and I are teaching our students mindful practices, we will also be teaching them about how the brain works in our study skills course. This way, they will be able to see how the puzzle pieces fit together.
- Like teaching any new activity or skill in the classroom, it’s important to explain the purpose of mindfulness. Why are we teaching you to be more mindful? What’s the purpose? How can these practices help you become a better student and individual citizen in our world? These are important questions to address with the students at the outset, which is why we are planning to begin our mindfulness unit with a TED Talk or video that visually shows the students why mindfulness is crucial to their future success in and out of the classroom.
- Short activities that allow students be more mindful in the moment will be good to use in all of our classes. Perhaps starting class with one minute of mindful breathing and quiet contemplation could help center the students and recalibrate their brains and bodies prior to jumping into the learning and content for the day. I want to use this in at least one class a day as I think it will really help the students see the benefits in stopping and pausing before continuing on with their day. Another simple yet mindful activity is to start class with a riddle. Having the students think about just the answer to the riddle allows them to hone their focus and concentration at the start of the class. This is also a cool idea that I want to use in our study skills class.
- When crafting the mindfulness curriculum for our class this year, I now have several good activities and ideas to include:
- After explaining the purpose of learning mindfulness, I want to have the students realize how many different thoughts are swirling around their tiny heads at any given moment by having them list every thought they are thinking during a period of 30 seconds. I will follow this up with a class discussion and reflection activity that will hopefully help the students see the power in decluttering their minds on a daily basis.
- I want to have the students complete some mindful speech and active listening activities to help the boys learn how to speak aloud and listen appropriately. The students will work with a partner to read a section of text aloud in various different ways before receiving feedback on each method. This way, hopefully, the students will be able to see how important volume, annunciation, and intonation are when speaking aloud. This activity will also help the students learn the importance of being good listeners and how this skill can help them and their partner grow as students and people.
- The author introduced a cool activity about walking with awareness to help the students see how their body language shows their feelings and emotions without them even knowing it. This will help the students learn to be aware of their body language and the messages it sends to their peers and teachers.
- Have students complete various acts of kindness and then talk about the resultant feelings. How does it feel to be kind and compassionate? Helping the students see the value in kindness will help them to treasure it and spread it to everyone they come in contact with on a daily basis.
- I want to have the students try a mindful seeing activity as a way to introduce how quiet observations can lead to mindful vision. We could work this into the STEM curriculum as they observe the natural world right outside of our classroom. How much more valuable are the observations they make when they are quiet and patient than when they are talking and focusing on several different ideas? This is something I struggled with this past year in my STEM class. When I took the students outside to observe their forest plots, they were so preoccupied with the external factors of bugs, heat, and their peers that they couldn’t mindfully observe their plots. Having the students practice this activity a few different times might help them to see the benefit in mindfully observing the world around them.
- Have the students complete an activity in which they discuss a hot button topic before seeing how their expectations and judgements cloud their mindfulness. How can you truly and objectively think about or discuss a topic if your mind is full of preconceived notions and subjective thoughts? Getting the students to see the importance of broadening their perspective when learning about new ideas or topics is crucial for mindful learning to take place.
- A great and easy way for the students to document their mindfulness progress is to have them reflect on their mindful thinking and learning in their e-portfolios. As we will have the students update and maintain their e-portfolio throughout the year, adding another component in which they can document their growth as a mindful student just makes sense. This way they can see how much more mindful they are at the end of the year compared to how they were at the start of the academic year.
While I didn’t totally love this book because it was disorganized and repetitive, I did learn a lot from it. Reading this text also facilitated much thinking for me on the topic of mindfulness. Although I wouldn’t recommend this book for teachers looking to create a mindfulness curriculum, it has helped me to think about how I want to organize my own unit on mindfulness. Now begins the fun work of setting up my mindfulness unit with all that I’ve learned from this resource.